Skip to content

Noah Hamilton Rose, famous Menardville photographer and 1937 Presidio photo

2011 November 20

Menard is the site of many historical events and famous people. One of those is a famous photographer from the 1800’s and early 1900’s; Noah Hamilton Rose, who spent his early years and began his career in Menardville.

The Rose family came to Menardville in 1884 and at the age of 14 in 1888 Noah began working as an apprentice in the office of the Menardville Monitor working for William Columbus Redman. This is where Rose began his self-taught photography career and took many early-day Menard county photos. There are many originals still being viewed today.

One original is the Rose photo of the 1937 event celebrating the rebuild of the “Old Fort San Saba” or the correct name is the Presidio de San Saba in Menard. I got this photo scanned and since 2007 you can buy a copy of this poster from the Menard County Historical Commission with funds benefiting the Menard Museum and the Presidio de San Saba Restoration Corporation.


Owned by Jan Wilkinson
The photo is 26″ long and 6″ wide, too big to see on this page.

Those known in the photo above; at the time of this writing, are shown below:

My husband’s mother, Laverne Bradford Wilkinson, in center with bangs and short hair, age 11.  One of the many Menard Elementary School students attending.

Buddy’s father, Francis Lamar Wilkinson, photographer for Menard News

Identified are Roger and Emmie Luckenbach Landers holding hand of son, Jake Landers (hat and overalls) and baby brother Fritz Landers in baby buggy (called the Luckenbach buggy at the Menardville Museum) with sister Susanna Landers Brown and two cousins Angela Luckenbach Crawford Connor and Sandra Spiller wearing bonnets.

Frank Tillman, Menard High School Indian

Bill Wilkinson (he told me he was age four) but by his birth date closer to six and sitting on the fence

Henry Reeve, producer of the celebration

I can’t help but think how different our little town would have been if we had been able to maintain and expand the use of the Presidio after the 1937 celebration and if we could have had a Historical and Research Center in conjunction with the museum and purchased the Noah H. Rose collection!

Unfortunately, the Noah H. Rose Collection was purchased by the Western History Collections in 1969. For more information visit the Western History Collections at the University of Oklahoma, Room 452, Monnet Hall, 630 Parrington Oval, Norman, Oklahoma, 73019.


Noah Hamilton Rose (April 9, 1874 – January 25, 1952), printer, photographer, and collector of photographs of the frontier West, was born seventy-five miles northwest of San Antonio in Kendall County on April 9, 1874, the son of Newton C. and Loutilda (White) Rose. In 1884, his father, a carpenter, moved his family to Menardville (now Menard). Rose was educated in rural schools and in 1888 at the age of 14 began working as an apprentice in the office of the Menardville Monitor. His family subsequently moved to Ballinger, where Rose worked on the local paper. In 1891, he returned to work on the Menardville Record. During this period he taught himself to take and develop photographs with a small box camera and printing supplies that he had received as a premium for selling subscriptions to the Youth’s Companion, a popular family weekly.

In 1892, he left Menardville to work at the Mason Herald. He spent the next thirty years working as an itinerant printer and photographer in Sonora, Menardville, Eagle Pass, Del Rio, and numerous small towns in West, Central, and North Texas. In addition to standard portrait work, he documented events such as the flood at Menardville in June 1899 and the 1902 land rush in Junction. While working in the Eagle Pass-Del Rio area in 1901 Rose began taking pictures of news events and developing them into lantern slides ready for projection the same day. He focused on such violent events as hangings and shoot-outs and interesting frontier figures-gunmen, sheriffs, politicians, judges. Rose began seeking out old photographs and corresponded with Emmett Dalton and other noted personalities to obtain pictures. From 1904 to 1919 he operated a photography studio in Del Rio and continued to build his collection of frontier photographs. He subsequently worked in central west Texas before settling in San Antonio in 1921. Rose’s early years there were inauspicious: he endured a long illness and thereafter suffered a fractured skull when he was hit by a car. Faced by a large debt for medical bills upon his recovery, he decided to focus his business exclusively on photographs of the old West. He made up a list of negatives that he had collected, printed a catalogue, and soon developed a booming mail-order business selling photographs to magazines, collectors, and writers.

According to Rose, pictures of such outlaws as Jesse and Frank James, Billy the Kid, Belle Starr, Jim and Bob Younger, and the Dalton gang were most in demand, followed in popularity by pictures of peace officers, Indians, Texas Rangers, and pioneers. He supplemented his stock by buying the rights to photographs owned by A. A. Brack, owner of Brack’s Studio of San Antonio, and eventually collected over 2,000 images. With his childhood friend John Marvin Hunter, Rose published an Album of Gunfighters in 1951. His collection of photographs was sold and is now in the collection of the University of Oklahoma in Norman.


  • J. Marvin Hunter, “Noah Rose, A Frontier Photographer”, Frontier Times, November 1935.
  • J. Marvin Hunter, “The Passing of a Life-Long Friend”, Frontier Times, February 1952.
  • Oran Warder Nolen, “Noah H. Rose, Frontier Cameraman,” Old West, Spring 1968.
  • Noah Hamilton Rose, A Catalog of the World Famous N. H. Rose Collection of Old Time Photographs of the Frontier (Houston: Frontier Pix, 1952).
Here are some of Noah Rose’s originals of the Presidio de San Saba in Menard with captions from the OU Collection.  Rose called it San Saba Mission as most folks in Menard still do today.

San Saba Mission ruins, 1895.
Destroyed by Apaches.
ROSE 294







San Saba Mission ruins, west side entrance, 1895.
ROSE 295

San Saba Mission ruins,
looking east, 1895.
ROSE 296

Stone at main entrance, San Saba Mission ruins, inscribed
with names, 1895.
ROSE 297


Men at San Saba Mission ruins, 1898.
ROSE 298

Previous Post
Next Post
11 Responses Post a comment
  1. February 18, 2024

    Thank you Wesley, that would be something to see!

  2. Wes permalink
    February 18, 2024

    I have preserved a bunch of of my uncle Rose’s negatives but still have a box full to go through. There’s some neat negatives in his collection. Saw alot of negatives of Indians, Texas Rangers and outlaws. I took the last known photo negative of Wild Bill and scanned it on my printer which then printed up as the actual photo. It was neat to see Wild Bill Hickok. I will send you some pictures of Noah’s things… I have his customer logs, original letters to Sam Bass’s sister and various negatives of some famous people like Doc, Billy, Wild Bill, Geronimo ect…

  3. February 17, 2024

    His work is very interesting and I would love to see your photos, if you can email them to me? [email protected] Thank you for reading my blog!!

  4. Linda Blalock permalink
    February 17, 2024

    I have an old photo of a man and woman that is pasted onto a black type of cardboard frame that folds. It has (Photo by Rose. Aug 1902) written in white ink or paint below the photo. Could this have been a photo by N.H. Rose? I looked online and have not been able to find any photos with this inscription. I also have another vintage photo of a group of people with N.H. Rose stamped on the back. Thank you in advance for your help.

  5. Westley Karcher permalink
    February 12, 2020

    My email address is westleykarcher at

    I can send you reversed negatives of some of his pictures also. I inherited a box of his things just before they demolished Katie and Sarah’s homes on Castroville Road.

  6. February 12, 2020

    Westley, I would love to see the photo you mention in your message to Deborah. History is wonderful.

  7. Westley Karcher permalink
    February 12, 2020

    I am related to you. My grandmother was Katie Lee Rose Karcher, Loutilda’s younger sister. Katie and Charles had 5 children. Nadine, Charlotte, William, Nancy and Gary. I’m one of William Karcher’s son. Somehow i inherted Noah Rose’s Bible. Whatever happened to Dessie Mae Rose? She was the youngest of the three girls from mother Sarah Elizabeth Milam Rose. You are aware that your are related to Benjamin Rush Milam right? I have a picture of James Brice Milam holding Ben Milam’s rifle with Katie, Dessie and Loutilda in the foreground. This photo was taken by Noah Rose.

  8. Deborah Vosburgh permalink
    January 4, 2020

    Noah Rose is my Great Uncle. My mother is 85 years old as of April 2019.
    She still tells stories about her Uncle and has lots of pictures of him.
    I would like to take my mother to Menard Tx to see some of the photos her Uncle Noah has there.

Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. The Presidio de San Saba in Menard County, Texas | Out My Kitchen Window
  2. John Warren Hunter and Menardville | Out My Kitchen Window
  3. Menardville Texas 1899 Flood | Out My Kitchen Window

Leave a Reply

Note: You may use basic HTML in your comments. Your email address will not be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.